Home | Sponsors | 2012 Ride for Mike


How do I show my way? Garmin or iPhone

Monday night I went out on a ride that had the primary purpose of getting my atrophied muscles some exercise. A side benefit was it also gave me a chance to test out a route tracing iPhone application. In yesterday’s post, I talked about the success of my primary goal. Today, I’d like to share my initial observations about the secondary one.

I’m not that excited about adding one more piece of technology to my bike. I find my Quarq CinQo powermeter and Garmin Edge 500 to be enough. Sure, I haul my cell phone around with me for that just in case need. However, that doesn’t have to do so much with my ride as it does with if I suddenly stop riding!

While making my plans for the 2010 Ride for Mike, I always intended it to be an interactive affair. That phone back there would play more of a role in that trip. The plan is to stop along the way and use my iPhone to send tweets out about my progress. With the iPhone 4, I’ll also able to take some HD video… if I happen to have anything worth catching on video.

Then I thought, wouldn’t it be cool if I could use the iPhone to allow people to follow me on my route in real time.  I started looking an application that could do it. Right now, the closest I have come is the Cyclemeter by Abvio. At least I know that it will track my route… whether it will allow people to follow me as I ride or if it will only allow them to see after I’ve finished is the question.

The application sends out a tweet when you start with a link to a map. I’m told that it updates my position every 5 minutes. So, my assumption is that if you click on the link during the time of my ride, you will see my progress within five minutes or less of that time. I’ve yet to test that part of it.

Of course, my greatest concern is with the AT&T network. The iPhone application might do a great job collecting the positioning data, but that doesn’t do me any good if I can get it up to the Web! My understanding is that the Cyclemeter software compensates for this by buffering until if finds a connection.

Then I wonder about the GPS accuracy. This isn’t as big of a deal, but consider these two maps from my Monday night right. The first is the one generated by my Garmin Edge 500. The second one is from the Cyclemeter software.

Cleveland Park route Garmin Edge 500

Garmin Edge 500 route from Monday

At first glance, the Cyclemeter route looks identical.

iPhone 4 GPS route of Cleveland Park

iPhone 4 Cyclemeter from Monday

Look closer and you will see that the Garmin GPS read a much tighter route than the iPhone one. Now, neither of them stayed dead on during the ride, but the iPhone one was a bit more wacky at times.

Wacky reads from the iPhone GPS

Close up of iPhone 4 GPS route

The Garmin data is much prettier…

Tighter Garmin Edge 500 tracking

Close up of Garmin Edge 500

It looks like this is the approach I’m going to have to take. I wish there was an ANT+ connection to the iPhone so that I could port the Garmin data through my iPhone to a server on the internet and display even more information from my ride. Still, this is about the investment I’ll need to make considering how many people will (or, more to the point won’t) be following my progress.

Do you use the Cyclemeter? Can you give me some advise? What type of battery life do you find you get? I’d also like to connect with some folks who would be willing to check in with me on my next ride. I’ll let you know when I plan the test and you can click on the link of the tweet that is sent out. We can figure out how it works together!

By the way, here are the links to the actual Google Maps routes that were generated Monday evening.

Finally, if you want to see what I would REALLY like to have for the 2010 Ride for Mike, check this out! Maybe The Worthwhile Company could do something like this for me next year!

Be Sociable, Share!

 

Tags: , ,

4 Responses to “How do I show my way? Garmin or iPhone”

  1. Jim Baker says:

    Hey Jonathan – nice blog entry. I’ve reviewed Cyclemeter on my blog jnb65.com and I like it. The remote tracking works great (my wife can see me on my ride) and I import the raw GPX data to RubiTrak on my Mac for a more detailed ride analysis. Missing things: cadence & heart rate capture; web based logging and ride sharing, insertion of rides into iCal or other calendar app. But Cyclemeter is way far ahead of the pack for features. The GPS is a bit wonky but for $4.99 I can live with that. If I was super serious I’d spend >$600 on Polar gear but I’m not…

  2. Yaniel says:

    Check out runkeeper pro (it has a cycling mode). It has a mode that allow people to track you real time. Check out their site at runkeeper.com

    I use the app for running and it works very well.

  3. wari says:

    What Yaniel forgot to mention is that live tracking is an Elite feature where you have to pay yearly for access (even though you have Runkeeper Pro). And unlike cyclemeter or endomondo, there’s no way for users to send feedback to you when you ride, only comments on workout page.

  4. jm says:

    There is now an ANT+ capable software for the iphone. The digitfit sensor connects to the iphone and allows the phone (with the appropriate software ipower,… offered by the same company), to collect speed, cadence, hear rate, etc. The company indicates that they will integrate their current offering with maps. I have not tried it, but it seems promising.

    Great review, by the way. I do wonder where this “lesser” quality tracking comes from. Is the iphone gps less capable than the Garmin’s? Less sensitive maybe?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

* Copy this password:

* Type or paste password here:

18,660 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>